Accident Damage Assessment Practices: Where Is the Justice?
Dr. Abdulhakim bin Abdullah Al-Kharji
As the Kingdom seeks to promote fairness among the parties to the insurance relationship, an issue has emerged that requires urgent attention: the mechanism used by insurance companies to assess vehicle damage.
The problem lies in the fact that financial compensation for consumers is often calculated based on a report from an accredited appraisal agency, without sufficient objective or technical consideration of the actual extent of the damage. It has become apparent that these agencies tend to estimate the cost of «repairing» the damaged part rather than replacing it, even in cases where replacement is the logical and technically sound option to ensure fairness.
This inadequate assessment leaves consumers facing three major problems:
- Compensation that is lower than the actual damage.
- No coverage for the period during which the vehicle is out of service while being repaired.
- Loss of the vehicle’s market value due to damage to key parts that were repaired rather than replaced.
More seriously, some of these assessments appear to be the result of an undeclared coordination between Insurance companies and appraisal agencies, thereby violating the principle of impartiality and undermining consumer protection.
Insurance fairness requires that the vehicle be restored to its pre-accident condition, rather than the injured party bearing the burden of an inaccurate assessment. Therefore, regulatory authorities—led by the Consumer Protection Authority and the Saudi Central Bank (SAMA)—must take action to:
– Re-establish appraisal standards and ensure their independence.
– Enabling consumers to challenge appraisals before impartial technical bodies.
– Requiring insurance companies to provide fair compensation, including for indirect damages.
In conclusion, it must be emphasized that a fair insurance system is not only about premiums but also about fair compensation; otherwise, the relationship between consumers and insurance companies will remain imbalanced, at the expense of the weaker party.
@Dr_alkharji



