إعلان
OMAINTEC

Dr. Abdulaziz bin Saad Al-Daghether writes for Amlak on Forex and the illusion of trading

Posted in

Advertisements have spread on Social media platforms and websites that promote trading from home with fantastical profits, through online trading in the buying and selling of foreign currencies to profit from price differentials (Forex), where the term "Forex" is an abbreviation for:

(Foreign Exchange market), meaning the foreign exchange market.

It takes several forms, the most important of which are:

  1. The company does not charge any commission on transactions, nor does it charge interest on overnight positions or margin...

This company gives $5 to every new subscriber with no strings attached,

However, when withdrawing funds, $7 is deducted from the balance only on the first withdrawal; no amount is deducted on subsequent withdrawals.

  • The way it works is that the company trades the amount on the international Forex market and charges a 2% annual commission on opening the account, in addition to 20% of the profits, so that the account holder shares in the company’s profits and losses, and there is no interest of any kind in this account, and the full amount plus profits can be withdrawn at any time.
  • 3- (High-Yield Investment Programs) Or what is known as HYIP in English HYIP, which are often involved in forex trading.

Sharia-related cautions regarding forex trading:

There are many, the most important of which are:

  1. That the broker in the forex market lends money to the client:
  2. either with interest, which is clearly prohibited,
  3. or on the condition that the client trades in the market through the broker,

This constitutes a combination of a loan and a swap contract, as they do not lend for free, but rather so that the client buys and sells through them, allowing them to profit from the spread. The following was stated in the ruling of the Fiqh Council: "Second: The broker’s condition that the customer conduct his trade through him leads to combining a loan with a barter (brokerage), which is equivalent to combining a loan with a sale—something prohibited by Islamic law, as stated by the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him: "It is not permissible to combine a loan with a sale…" This hadith was narrated by Abu Dawood (3/384) and al-Tirmidhi (3/526), who said: “A hasan sahih hadith.” By doing so, the broker has derived a benefit from his loan, and the jurists have agreed that any loan from which a benefit is derived constitutes prohibited usury. An example of this is the method of leverage, whereby the forex broker provides the trader with leverage of up to $100,000 for every $1,000 in the account. In other words, the broker requires that a certain amount be deposited in the client’s account so that the support provided to the client is proportional to that amount, and that the broker charges a specific percentage on every buy or sell transaction as profit; this is called margin trading (margin trading),  which means the broker lends the client a multiple of the amount with which the account was opened. Therefore, what the broker takes from the client is riba, and the profit the broker derives from the client’s transactions is riba because it results from the benefit of the loan.

Lending what one does not have and selling what one does not own

  1. In this market, the broker, in the case of a loan, lends what he does not have, and the client sells what he does not own. Speculation in currencies in this market is entirely digital and fictitious; the broker does not actually own the amount he deposits into the client’s account; rather, it is merely a commitment on the broker’s part, nor does the client is actually speculating; there is no actual delivery or receipt, but rather currencies are traded as numbers, and the transaction is not recorded in the accounts until two business days later. This is prohibited based on the hadith of "Abdullah ibn "Amr y, who said: He said: The Messenger of Allah r said, "It is not permissible to combine a loan with a sale, nor to include two conditions in a sale, nor profit on something not guaranteed, nor the sale of something you do not possess." (Narrated by Abu Dawud in his Sunan, no. 3506.) And in the hadith of Hakim ibn Hizam, he said: ”O Messenger of Allah, a man comes to me wanting to buy something I do not have. Should I buy it for him from the market?” He replied: “Do not sell what you do not have” (Narrated by Abu Dawood in his Sunan, no. 3503).

Decision of the Islamic Fiqh Council:

The Islamic Fiqh Council has ruled that it is not permissible for the beneficiary to dispose of the currency during the grace period until after the bank entry has taken effect and actual delivery is possible.

  1. A company that deals in forex sells currencies or assets that are not under its control—indeed, it has not yet taken possession of them—and this is prohibited, because one of the conditions of a currency exchange contract is that the commodity being sold must be owned by the seller and under his guarantee; the commodity may be owned by the seller but not under his guarantee—such as when he has not yet received it from the original seller. Therefore, the text prohibiting both scenarios is found in the hadith of Ibn "Amr y, attributed to the Prophet (peace be upon him): " "There is no profit in what is not guaranteed, nor is there a sale of what is not in your possession,” (Narrated by Abu Dawood in his Sunan, no. 3506). And from ”Atab ibn Asid t, who said that when the Messenger of Allah r sent him to Mecca, "he forbade him from selling what he did not guarantee" (narrated by Ibn Majah in his *Sunan*, no. 2189), and the Messenger of Allah r’s statement: “Profit is contingent upon guarantee,” as recorded by Abu Dawud in his *Sunan*, no. 3510, p. 3/304.
  2. One of the most significant legal issues in forex trading is that the contract includes what is known as “overnight fees,” which are interest charges imposed on the investor if the transaction is not settled on the same day.The ruling of the Fiqh Council states, first: “As for the explicit riba it contains—represented by the increase over the loan amount, known as ‘overnight fees’—it constitutes prohibited riba.”
  3. The lack of physical delivery in the sale of currencies, gold, and silver constitutes riba al-nasi’ah. The ruling of the Council states: “The buying and selling of currencies often takes place without lawful physical delivery that would permit the transaction.”

Harm to the economy:

6- The ruling of the Fiqh Council included the following: “Fourth: Because this transaction entails economic harm to the transacting parties, especially the client (investor), and to the economy of society in general. This is because it is based on the accumulation of debt and risk-taking, and often involves deception, misinformation, and rumors, as well as monopolization, price manipulation, and sharp, rapid price fluctuations, with the aim of getting rich quickly and seizing the savings of others through unlawful means, which makes it akin to consuming wealth unjustly, in addition to diverting funds in society from genuine, productive economic activities to these economically unproductive economically unproductive ventures, which may lead to severe economic shocks that inflict catastrophic losses and damage on society.”