Commercial Real Estate Disputes: Why Are They Escalating Despite Improvements in Regulations?

The rise in disputes is linked to poor contract drafting and a lack of governance and risk management, not to a lack of sophisticated real estate regulations.
Evidence Law - Real Estate Transactions - Companies Law

Posted in

In recent years, the real estate sector in the Kingdom has witnessed rapid regulatory and legislative developments, which have led to an improved investment environment and enhanced documentation, regulation, and oversight, Nevertheless, commercial real estate disputes continue to rise, whether between developers and investors, among partners, or between owners, operators, financiers, and contractors.

This raises an important question:
If regulations are constantly evolving, why do real estate disputes on the rise?
Practical experience confirms that the problem often lies not in the absence of regulations, but in how contractual and operational relationships are managed from the outset.
Many real estate projects begin with high investment enthusiasm, while legal and regulatory aspects are treated as a subsequent phase or mere formalities, leading to imbalances early on before a dispute actually arises.

Weak Contract Drafting
One of the most prominent causes of escalating commercial real estate disputes is weak contract drafting, as some contracts are still based on general or imprecise language, or are copied from ready-made templates that do not reflect the nature of the actual project, which opens the door to differing interpretations and conflicting obligations at the first operational or financial crisis.
Furthermore, many contracts focus more on the signing phase than on the implementation phase, whereas reality shows that most disputes do not arise when the contract is drafted, but rather when circumstances change, delays occur, projects stall, or expectations between the parties diverge.

Lack of Governance Within the Project
The situation becomes even more complicated when there is a lack of clear governance within the real estate project, leading to overlapping authorities, multiple decision-making centers emerge, and oversight of financial and operational aspects weakens, leading to the escalation of disputes and their transformation from simple operational issues into complex legal and commercial disputes.

Another recurring issue is weak legal risk management, as some real estate entities treat risks as remote possibilities, whereas real estate projects are, by their very nature, associated with multiple risks:
regulatory, financial, construction-related, marketing, operational, and contractual. Any shortcoming in managing these aspects may directly affect the stability of the project and the contractual relationships associated with it.

Lack of Disclosure and Clarity Among the Parties
Furthermore, some disputes are not so much the result of regulatory errors as they are the result of a lack of disclosure and clarity among the parties; The higher the level of transparency from the outset, the lower the likelihood of conflict later on.
For this reason, many major real estate cases could have had their impact mitigated or been prevented altogether if the following had been in place:
A clear, professionally drafted contract.
A precise allocation of responsibilities.
Clear decision-making mechanisms.
Effective risk management.
Genuine internal oversight.
Systematic documentation of correspondence and commitments.

Professional legal management: “Prevention”
It is important to realize that the judiciary—no matter how competent it may be — often steps in to address the consequences of a problem after it has occurred, whereas professional legal management aims primarily to prevent disputes or reduce their likelihood before they reach the litigation stage.
Given the significant expansion of real estate projects and related investments, there is an urgent need to raise legal and administrative awareness within the real estate sector—not only from the perspective of regulatory compliance, but also from the perspective of building a stable and sustainable contractual and regulatory environment.

Stability in the real estate market is achieved not only through the existence of regulations, but also through the quality of their enforcement, the clarity of contracts, efficient management, and high standards of governance and transparency within projects.
Therefore, the future of the real estate sector will not be measured solely by the scale of development or rising prices, but also by the extent to which real estate entities are able to manage their relationships, obligations, and risks in a professional manner that minimizes disputes, protects investments, and ensures sustainability.
@Dr_alkharji